Victorian Oil Portrait of a Lady Knitting, Possibly Lady Laing 1831–1913 John Maler Collier
Attributed to John Maler Collier – Victorian Portrait of a Lady Knitting, Possibly Lady Laing (1831–1913), c.1893–1900
An imposing signed British society portrait of a distinguished mature woman knitting in a green upholstered armchair, preserved in a period Richard Turley frame and bearing striking parallels with Collier’s documented 1893 portrait of Lady Laing.
Highlights
• Attributed to The Hon. John Maler Collier OBE RP ROI (1850–1934)
• Circa 1893–1900
• Oil on canvas
• Signed “John Collier” in red, lower left
• Large three-quarter-length society portrait
• Mature female sitter depicted knitting
• Sitter presently unidentified; Lady Laing (1831–1913) is an important newly identified possibility
• Collier’s documented 1893 portrait of Lady Laing also depicts her engaged in knitting/needlework
• Approximately 103 × 81.5 cm / 40.6 × 32.1 inches
• Presented beneath protective glass
• Substantial period giltwood and composition frame
• Richard Turley trade label retained verso
• Richard Turley documented as Collier’s framemaker
• Mellors & Kirk, Nottingham, 14 January 2021, Lot 718
• Acquired directly from the above auction by the present owner
Introduction
An imposing late Victorian British portrait attributed to John Maler Collier (1850–1934), depicting an elegantly dressed mature woman seated in a deep green upholstered armchair while engaged in knitting.
The portrait combines the scale and dignity of commissioned society portraiture with an unusually intimate domestic activity. Against a restrained dark background, the sitter’s face, hands, lace, jewellery and knitting are carefully articulated, while the green upholstery provides the composition’s principal colour contrast.
Recent research has revealed an especially significant comparison within Collier’s accepted oeuvre.
In 1893 Collier painted Lady Laing (1831–1913), wife of the distinguished shipbuilder Sir James Laing. That securely identified portrait, now associated with the Laing Art Gallery, likewise represents its mature female sitter seated and engaged in knitting or needlework.
The discovery does not establish that the present woman is Lady Laing. However, the combination of artist, approximate period, sitter age and the highly distinctive knitting motif makes the documented 1893 portrait an important comparator and raises Lady Laing as a serious subject for further investigation.
Catalogue Details
Artist: Attributed to The Hon. John Maler Collier OBE RP ROI (1850–1934)
Title: Portrait of a Lady Knitting
Date: Circa 1893–1900
Medium: Oil on canvas
Signature: Signed “John Collier” in red, lower left
School: British School
Period: Late Victorian
Genre: Society Portrait / Female Portrait
Subject: Unidentified mature lady knitting in a green upholstered armchair; possibly Lady Laing (1831–1913)
Canvas dimensions: Approximately 103 × 81.5 cm
Canvas dimensions in inches: Approximately 40.6 × 32.1 inches
Frame: Substantial period giltwood and composition frame retaining the Richard Turley trade label
Glazing: Presented beneath protective glass
Catalogue Note
The attribution is supported by several mutually compatible strands of evidence.
When offered by Mellors & Kirk Fine Art & Antiques, Nottingham, on 14 January 2021 as Lot 718, the painting was catalogued without qualification as The Hon. John Collier, OBE (1850–1934) – Portrait of a Lady Knitting Seated in a Green Armchair.
Mellors & Kirk recorded the red signature, oil-on-canvas medium, 103 × 81.5 cm dimensions and original Richard Turley frame. The work was also described as being in good original unlined condition beneath glass.
The present catalogue adopts the more conservative designation Attributed to John Maler Collier, distinguishing the previous auction attribution from independent technical authentication.
Particularly significant comparative evidence has now been identified in Collier’s accepted 1893 portrait of Lady Laing (1831–1913). That painting measures approximately 142 × 111 cm and also represents Lady Laing seated while engaged in needlework or knitting.
Collier painted both Sir James Laing and Lady Laing in 1893, their portraits surviving with consecutive Laing Art Gallery collection numbers, demonstrating a coordinated Laing family portrait commission.
The present portrait is compositionally different and considerably smaller. No documentary evidence presently proves that it represents Lady Laing, nor has a documented second version of Collier’s Lady Laing portrait yet been located.
The comparison nevertheless provides an unusually close parallel within Collier’s documented portrait practice and justifies continued investigation of Lady Laing as a possible sitter.
The Sitter – Possibly Lady Laing
The sitter remains formally unidentified.
Recent comparative research has raised Theresa Talbot Laing, Lady Laing (1831–1913) as a potentially important candidate.
Collier’s documented 1893 portrait of Lady Laing depicts a mature woman seated and engaged in knitting or needlework — an unusually close iconographic parallel with the present composition.
Lady Laing would have been approximately 61–62 years old in 1893, compatible with the apparent maturity of the present sitter.
There are also areas of facial and presentational compatibility, although differences in head angle, lighting, costume and composition make visual comparison alone insufficient for identification.
The documented Lady Laing portrait is a different, larger canvas measuring approximately 142 × 111 cm. No surviving archival evidence presently establishes that Collier painted a second portrait or smaller version of Lady Laing.
Consequently, “possibly Lady Laing” must presently be understood as a research hypothesis rather than an established identification.
Further examination of Collier’s surviving Sitter Book and Laing family archival material may prove decisive.
About Lady Laing
Theresa Talbot Laing (1831–1913) was the wife of prominent Sunderland shipbuilder Sir James Laing (1823–1901).
The couple occupied an important position within nineteenth-century Sunderland society, and Lady Laing was associated particularly with charitable and civic activity.
In 1893 John Collier painted portraits of both Sir James and Lady Laing. The surviving Lady Laing portrait depicts her seated and occupied with needlework, providing an unusually relevant comparison with the present painting.
The two documented Laing portraits carry consecutive museum collection numbers, further indicating that they formed part of the same portrait commission.
The Artist
John Maler Collier (1850–1934) was one of the prominent British portrait painters of the late Victorian and Edwardian periods.
Educated at Eton, he studied at the Slade School of Fine Art and subsequently in Munich and Paris.
Collier developed an extensive portrait practice encompassing leading personalities from science, politics, literature, military life, society and the arts.
His portraiture is distinguished by naturalistic observation, psychological presence and careful differentiation of flesh, textiles, jewellery and surrounding materials.
His works are represented in major public collections including the National Portrait Gallery and Tate.
The Richard Turley Frame
The substantial period frame retains the printed trade label of Richard Turley, Carver and Gilder, Looking Glass and Picture Frame Maker, 21 Crogsland Road, Kentish Town, London.
Turley was established at this address from 1891, making a date around 1893 entirely compatible with the physical evidence of the frame.
Of particular attributional importance, John Collier subsequently referred to Turley as “my framemaker” in 1898.
The frame does not independently authenticate the painting, but its association with a craftsman demonstrably employed by Collier provides valuable supporting historical context.
Mellors & Kirk described the frame in 2021 as the original frame.
Provenance
Mellors & Kirk Fine Art & Antiques, Nottingham, 14 January 2021, Lot 718.
Catalogued as The Hon. John Collier, OBE (1850–1934) – Portrait of a Lady Knitting Seated in a Green Armchair, signed in red, oil on canvas, 103 × 81.5 cm, in the original frame by Richard Turley.
Acquired directly from the above sale by the present owner in 2021.
Earlier provenance presently unspecified.
Dimensions
Canvas:
Height: approximately 103 cm / 40.6 inches
Width: approximately 81.5 cm / 32.1 inches
Frame depth: approximately 10 cm / 3.9 inches
Condition Report
Offered in antique condition commensurate with age.
Mellors & Kirk recorded the painting in 2021 as being in good original unlined condition beneath glass.
The canvas appears to remain unlined. Areas of age-related craquelure and surface ageing are visible.
A small tear or puncture is present towards the lower portion of the canvas with a corresponding tape or patch repair visible verso.
The substantial period frame displays rubbing, cracking, chips and local losses consistent with age.
Please study all photographs carefully as they form an integral part of the condition report.
Shipping
Worldwide shipping is available.
Owing to the substantial dimensions and weight of the framed portrait, it will be professionally packaged using appropriate protective materials and dispatched fully insured.
International buyers are welcome. Please contact us for a destination-specific delivery quotation or to discuss any particular shipping requirements.
Certificate of Sale & Dealer Attribution
The artwork will be supplied with a Certificate of Sale & Dealer Attribution issued by Cheshire Antiques Consultant LTD®, recording the artwork’s catalogue details, attribution, provenance as stated, and details of the sale. This document accompanies the work as part of its ongoing ownership and provenance record.
Attribution and Research
The historical observations, provenance research, attribution analysis and contextual commentary presented within this catalogue entry represent the professional opinion of Cheshire Antiques Consultant LTD®. They are offered in good faith as informed scholarly assessments based upon the available evidence, comparative research, published reference material and our experience within the international fine art market.
These observations should be understood as professional opinions rather than definitive statements of fact or guarantees of authorship, attribution, date, origin, provenance or historical interpretation. As with all historic works of art, future documentary discoveries, technical examination, conservation analysis or advances in academic research may refine, expand or revise current interpretations.
Cheshire Antiques Consultant LTD®
Specialising in carefully curated British and European fine art, antiques and historic works of art.
Every artwork is professionally researched and catalogued using comparative scholarship, published reference material and more than two decades of experience within the international fine art market. We are committed to offering collectors works of artistic and historical merit accompanied by transparent provenance research, detailed catalogue descriptions and professional, client-focused service.
Additional photographs and further information are available upon request.
